The Fallacy of Grievance Based Terrorism

The myth of Islamist Imperialism being the result of Muslim communities reacting to “unfair” American foreign policy is sited by both far left Anti-American pundits as well those on the far right whose anti-semitism is served by such nonsense.

History debunks this madness but truthfully history has become a subject unpopular among Americans, especially those of a leftward bent, who instead prefer a more “progressive” understanding of reality that demands the willful ignorance of historical fact and the radical re-imagining of our present reality. From The Fallacy of Grievance Based Terrorism by Melvin E. Lee:

The fundamental premise of much scholarly examination and public discourse is that grievances with U.S. policies in the Middle East motivate Islamist terrorism. Such assumptions, though, misunderstand the enemy and its nature. In reality, the conflict is sparked not by grievance but rather by incompatibility between Islamist ideology and the natural rights articulated during the European Enlightenment and incorporated into U.S. political culture. Acquiescing to political grievances will not alter the fundamental incompatibility between Lockean precepts of tolerance and current interpretations of Islam: Only Islam’s fundamental reform will resolve the conflict.

Many scholars mark the post-World War I partition of the Ottoman Empire as the origin of Islamist opposition to the West.[1] The idea that the Middle East would be a tolerant, prosperous contributor to the global environment today if World War I victors had left intact the Ottoman Empire is a premise in the literature accompanying the rise of twentieth-century jihadism. Historian David Fromkin argued in his influential A Peace to End All Peace that present day Muslim unrest is the direct result of Winston Churchill’s early twentieth-century decisions.[2] British journalist Robert Fisk also holds British officials responsible although he prefers to blame Arthur Balfour, foreign secretary between 1916 and 1919.[3] Both authors are wrong, though, to base their theories of grievance on such arbitrary demarcation of eras. The roots of jihadism and its opposition to the United States as part of the non-Muslim West were cast long before World War I erupted. The interaction between the United States and Muslim states and societies dates back to American independence.[4] Contemporary jihadism is not the result of accumulated grievance; rather it has for cultural reasons been an integral factor in Islamic societies’ interaction with the United States.

Jihadism has targeted Americans for our entire existence. North African Muslims preyed upon American merchants as soon as we gained our independence. The Ottoman empire used the threat of violence not only against us to gain concessions, but they used our good natures against us by threatening to exterminate the Christians and Jews in their territories:

Almost immediately after independence, the U.S. government found itself in conflict with the Barbary sheikhdoms of Morocco, Tunis, Algiers, and Tripoli. For centuries, these states filled their coffers by piracy, stealing cargoes, enslaving crew, and collecting ransom. European sea-going nations often entered into treaty and tribute arrangements with the Barbary leaders in order to buy immunity and curtail competition.[5] In 1784, Moroccan pirates hijacked the U.S. merchant ship Betsy in the Mediterranean and enslaved her crew. A year later, Algerine pirates seized two more vessels, the Maria from Boston and the Dauphin from Philadelphia. The U.S. ministers to England and France, John Adams and Benjamin Franklin, and Thomas Jefferson oversaw a peace treaty with Morocco, but the Algerine leadership refused any accommodation. In 1796, President George Washington ordered construction of six warships to form a U.S. navy and to protect U.S. shipping from Barbary pirates. In 1801, in the wake of an upsurge in piracy, President Thomas Jefferson entered into war with Tripoli, bombarding the city three years later and winning the release of American hostages.[6] Peace did not last. With the U.S. military embroiled in the War of 1812, Algerine pirates again began terrorizing American crewmen and disrupting U.S. trade. They miscalculated. In 1815, President James Madison dispatched a squadron of U.S. Navy frigates, which defeated the pirate fleet and won reparations from Algiers, Tunis, and Tripoli.[7]

The rationale for the predation of the Barbary corsairs was not based in opposition to American political maneuvering, the so called “blow back” of the Ron Paul crowd, but instead in religious ideology:

What Americans and Europeans saw as piracy, Barbary leaders justified as legitimate jihad. Jefferson related a conversation he had in Paris with Ambassador Abdrahaman of Tripoli who told him that all Christians are sinners in the context of the Qur’an and that it was a Muslim’s “right and duty to make war upon them wherever they could be found, and to enslave as many as they could take as prisoners.”[11] Islam gave great incentive to fighting infidels, Abdrahaman explained, because the Qur’an promised that making war against infidels ensured a Muslim paradise after death.[12] Richard O’Brien, the imprisoned captain of the Philadelphia merchantman Dauphin and later the U.S. consul to Algiers, related similar conversations with ‘Ali Hasan, the ruler of Algiers.[13] Ottoman leaders used the same rationale to justify the enslavement and trading of captives from the Balkans, Caucasus, and Ukraine.[14]

The role that jihadi ideology played in the Barbary wars is documented with explicit references to jihad and holy war in the treaties that U.S. officials entered into with Muslim rulers. Tunis and Algiers, as the western outposts of the Ottoman Empire, even described themselves to American envoys as the “frontier posts of jihad against European Christianity.

The article is a good one and goes on to examine that the theory of American policy angering Muslims is a bizarre one considering America’s pro-Arab, pro-Islamic stances which lasted well into the 21st century. At the heart of the matter isn’t American support for Israel or “exploitation” of the third world, but Islamic countries embrace of Jihadism and rejection of modernism:

The failure of Islamic states to incorporate the Enlightenment’s advances in thought has caused their stagnation, if not decline, over the last several centuries. In contrast, the incorporation of Enlightenment and democratic principles into Western governance has resulted in history’s most rapid improvement in the human condition. Only those Muslim countries that have embraced, in some fashion, Western principles of democracy, free markets, property rights, tolerance, and the rule of law have prospered. Most Arab states refuse. Bernard Lewis, perhaps the doyen of Middle East studies in the Western world, explained, “By all indicators from the United Nations, the World Bank, and other authorities, Muslim countries—in matters such as job creation, education, technology, and productivity—lag ever further behind the West. Even worse, the Arab nations also lag behind the more recent recruits to Western style modernity, such as Korea, Taiwan, and Singapore.”[36] All majority Muslim countries except Qatar, Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, and Turkey, which have recently adopted significant free market and democratic reforms, rank in the bottom half of world productivity; of the rest, only Morocco, Indonesia, Saudi Arabia, and Bangladesh reach the third quartile.[37] According to the World Bank, the average per capita income of all majority Muslim countries collectively is less than half of the average for the globe. Only Kuwait approaches the global average life expectancy;[38] all other Muslim majority states lag in the bottom half of the world in this important measure of health.

Jihadis thrive in such stagnated conditions. This leads to negative annuity: Jihadism both grows amid stagnation and fuels stagnation. It accelerated coincident with the European Enlightenment and the relative decline of the Muslim Middle East. At its core, jihadism is a violent rejection of many of the fundamental principles of the European Enlightenment. Democracy, free markets, tolerance and freedom of religion, secular government, and separation between the religious, the political, and the individual spark religious fury. It is no coincidence, then, that jihadis, under the banner of cleansing their religion of evil Western influence, have focused their attentions on the United States, the clearest manifestation of the European Enlightenment today. They will continue to threaten Western civilization until they are checked.

Read the whole article, if nothing else it’ll provide you with plenty of ammunition to shoot down the the flighty arguments of those who would tell you Islamists would stop their violence if only America would stop supporting Jews/buying oil/ exporting our culture etc.

h/t American Congress for Truth

Jewish Teen Beaten in Hate Attack … In New York

And thus the liberal “anti-Zionist” activism of groups like Adalah-NY bear their poisonious fruits at last:

A 16-year-old Yeshiva student who told cops he was beaten by five black teens shouting hate-filled slurs said Sunday the attack has left him terrified – fearful of even walking outside his Brooklyn home.

A medical staple juts from a deep gash in the side of Samuel Balkany’s head, a grim reminder of the ambush in Crown Heights at 10.30 p.m. on Friday.

“They were saying, ‘Oh, little Jew boy, you think you own this neighborhood,'” Samuel said. “‘Who are you, f—ing Jew?'”

Samuel, a Lubavitch Hasidic, said he exchanged no words with the teens before the attack.

They were not trying to rob him, he said.

“I was just getting clobbered,” added Samuel, who said doctors told him the attackers must have used a rock or some other sharp object.

“I was screaming for help but nobody was there.”

After the beating, Samuel ran to his friend’s house, where his pal’s mother called 911.

“I have a lot of deep holes in my head, one deep gash,” he said. “All over my body, I have black and blue marks.”

Cops were investigating the beating as a possible hate crime.

“A possible hate crime” they say. It’s more than possible but New Yorkers are unwilling to admit their pretensions about an inclusive and diverse New York are largely a lie built upon the willful blindness of New Yorkers to the poisonous atmosphere their radical leftist propaganda has created. Jews have become a popular target for scape goating amongst the left once again, with attitudes like this from the Daily News comments section on the above story not as rare in the Big Apple as people would think:

nothatdumb Jan 30, 2008 10:01:01 AM

if jewish people like or not my position of not supporting them or their claims. I just don’t by their **** and pity claims of being victims of the evil of the world. Maybe if they loose their arrogant and greedy attitude, people will sympathize with their claims when something bad happens. The world isn’t that evil to decide to conspired against jewish people, is the jewish people that has conspire against all who are not like them. If you go to any part of the world, if you look to any time of the world, if you look into all the different cultures, all of them have expressed dislike towards to the jewish people, isn’t something limited to just one people, just to one culture or just to an isolate incident in the history, it has been like this always, at least for 3000 years, and will always be until the day the jewish people decide to fit into the world and not try to make the world to fit into them.

I’ve heard rants like this several times from New Yorkers, usually high school kids who “learned some facts” from one of their teachers. I guess diversity training for teachers skips over Germany in the early 20th century.

The teen was a Hasidic Jew and of course the insular, volatile community is nearing a boiling point. Comments on this story from a local Jewish website call for violent attacks on Blacks:

rage wrote:

we should show them what a good beating means.
here’s what we do. we rome the streets. if we find more then three colored teenagers walking together, we confront them. start asking them questions.
and ask them to go home.
if they refuse, that’s when the beating should start.
none of them should be able to walk after the beating. they must be hospitolized…
just pump the streets with fire. fight fire with fire.
Kahana Chai.
“every jew- A 22”

01/19/08 – 19:41 –

I bet replacing the ideal of assimilation with multiculturalism doesn’t look so great to New York liberals now.

h/t Save Brooklyn Now!

Child Rapists Should be Eligible for the Death Penalty

A disgusting story from Connecticut where two degenerates were raping children as young a three months old as part of what looks like a child porn production scheme. The men had no “type” or age preference only a sadistic desire to inflict sexual violence on people who were weaker and more vulnerable than themselves. From WFSB:

NEW BRITAIN, Conn. — Two men in police custody who sexually assaulted a 3-month-old girl posted proof on the Internet, police said.

New Britain police announced the arrests Thursday of Harold Spurling, 39, and Jeffrey Brisson, 29, both of New Britain. Both men face charges that date as far back as eight years ago and involve children.

Channel 3 Eyewitness News reporter Len Besthoff reported the assistant state’s attorney in the case revealed more about the character of the pair during arraignment at New Britain Superior Court on Thursday.

The prosecutor said about one of the men “he had significant sexual contact with minors.” About the other man, the prosecutor said, “He is a grave danger to the community.”

[…]

Investigators said evidence seized from the pair includes pictures that depict child pornography and a video that police said shows Brisson sexually assaulting the 3-month-old girl.

Both were charged with multiple counts of sexual assault and risk of injury to a child by sexual contact, in addition to tampering with evidence and interfering with a search warrant. The arrest warrants for both men were sealed as they were set to face arraignment in court on Thursday.

Detectives received anonymous information that the pair were involved in pedophilia that involved the Internet this month. Police said the pair sexually assaulted a 14-year-old boy.

[…]

“The two accused knew the police were outside and were refusing to allow access into the apartment,” New Britain police Sgt. Darren Pearson said. “It’s believed that they were trying to dispose of the evidence, start the encryption process while the police officers waited outside. The officers forced entry and went inside.”

Officers said they saw thumbnail icons of child pornography on a computer inside the apartment, and detectives said they watched the video that showed Brisson and the 3-month-old girl.

“When they looked on the desktop, there was an icon that they believed depicted child pornography,” Pearson said. “Upon further examination of that video clip, they determined that Mr. Brisson had sexually assaulted that 3-month-old, that infant that was on scene.”

They raped infants. They raped teen age boys. They’d probably rape adults too if given the chance. These two are not mentally ill pedophiles who can be rehabilitated with treatment, but are soulless monsters who choose to inflict pain and suffering on children for profit.

They are a danger to the community now, they will be a danger to other prisoners when they are incarcerated, and they will be dangerous to anyone they come into contact with in the future. The only way to end their reign of evil is to end their lives and take from them the ability to spread their taint further.